HN Reader

401

Great guide! I think the first "My first RISC-V assembly program" emulator plane should be right at the beginning of the guide. Otherwise, casual readers might think that this is a text-only introduction (despite the word "interactive" in the title).

Will spend more time on it in the coming days. I am quite interested in RISC-V and I think that it might have a bright future ahead.

If any AI expert is reading this now, please use Replit or Lovable or something like that to re-create "Core War" [0] with RISC-V assembly. It would be GREAT.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Core_War

3 months agoby simonebrunozzi

Having learned assembly with the book "Computer Organization And Design" from Patterson and Hennessy, it really shows how much RISC-V takes from MIPS. After all they share some of the people involved in both ISAs and they have learned from the MIPS mistakes (no delay slots!). Basically if you come from a MIPS the assembly is very very similar, as it was my case.

Now that book is also available with a RISC-V edition, which has a very interesting chapter comparing all different RISC ISAs and what they do differently (SH, Alpha, SPARC, PA-RISC, POWER, ARM, ...),...

However I've been exploring AArch64 for some time and I think it has some very interesting ideas too. Maybe not as clean as RISC-V but with very pragmatic design and some choices that make me question if RISC-V was too conservative in its design.

3 months agoby aarroyoc

https://github.com/triilman25/tcp-socket-in-riscv-assembly

I wrote TCP Socket for RISCV by using ISA RV64I. You have to know about linker relaxation and how to using it. Some of reference I have attached there

3 months agoby triilman

I think there's an error in the Position Independence section:

    start:
        auipc a0, 3
        addi a0, a0, 4

The text says that this should result in 0x3004; was this example intended to be

    start:
        lui a0, 3
        addi a0, a0, 4

3 months agoby cbm-vic-20

The gods have spoken.

I have reached “intro to assembly” in my C course this week and had decided on RISC-V to bridge the gap that everyone has different CPUs and that x86-64 is a little harder to learn than MIPS32, but MIPS32 isn’t as relevant.

And here’s someone who made my course material for the subject entirely.

Thank you so much.

3 months agoby sshine

I have to praise the interactive style of this content.

As a C/C++ dev, I've always thought assembly was much harder. But this interactive content makes assembly clearer.

3 months agoby liqilin1567

Even if there are not that expensive to implement, I do not use official ABI register names, neither pseudo-instructions (I use a command to generate the code on the side).

Once RISC-V has performant silicon implementations (server/desktop/mobile/embedded), the really hard part will be to move the software stack, mostly closed source applications like video games.

And a very big warning: do NOT abuse an assembler macro-preprocessor or you will lock your code on that very assembler. On my side I have been using a simple C pre-processor to keep the door open for any other assembler, at minimal technical cost.

3 months agoby sylware

> Subtracting from zero is negation. What’s the negative of 0x123?

It is 0xfffffedd.

> Hmm, we get 0xfffffccd.

No, we didn't. The emulator shows 0xfffffedd, and I've checked it manually. The emulator is right.

3 months agoby ordu

This really makes me want to try fiddling with some low-level stuff again. I studied mechatronics at uni and programmed microcontrollers in C and assembly, but have gone the webdev direction since then. Does anyone have any trusted quality resources for getting into RISC-V hardware? I'm especially interested in using Rust for this if possible - I've wanted an excuse to learn it in more depth for a while.

3 months agoby crabmusket

RISK-V - you can easily get the hardware: https://www.raspberrypi.com/news/risc-v-on-raspberry-pi-pico...

3 months agoby Peteragain

if you're looking for an nice RISCV emulator try RARS https://github.com/TheThirdOne/rars

3 months agoby bigprovolone